Hard Facts
1. Michael and Walt made it back to civilization over two months after the crash of Flight 815 which places their return towards the end of November 2004.
2. Walt, who is traumatized by his experiences, no longer wishes to speak to Michael.
3. Michael, who lives in New York City, is unable to commit suicide because the Island won’t let him. [NOTE: One wonders why Michael just didn’t jump off a bridge. There are so many of them in New York.]
4. Michael is haunted by Libby.
5. Tom (who is gay) makes it off the Island to recruit Michael.
6. Some (but not all) of the Others can come and go from the Island as they please.
7. Sayyid rats out Michael to the Barge’s captain.
8. People appearing to be mercenaries engage in shooting practice with semi-automatic weapons on the Barge.
9. Ben suggests that Alex seek refuge in the Temple.
10. Carl and Rosseau join Alex in going to the Temple.
11. Carl and Rosseau are shot on their way to the Temple.
The Observations of a Manhattan Resident
The Manhattan of LOST’s imagination bears no relationship to the Manhattan of today or 2004. There is no place in Manhattan with a private house of the sort in which Michael’s mother supposedly lives. There may be some brownstones but no houses of that sort. Maybe there are some houses like that in some of the outer boroughs but the premise of the episode is that it all takes place in Manhattan. Also, give Bloomberg some credit, even post-Guliani you just can’t walk into a pawn shop and get a gun especially in exchange for a Rolex with a Korean inscription. Otherwise, LOST is completely accurate as Manhattan is, in fact, an island too.
Analysis
1. The identity of the Oceanic Six. Jack, Kate, Hurley, Sayyid, Aaron and Sun. I guess Sawyer does not make the cut.
2. The Barge operatives killed Rosseau and Carl. One’s initial reaction might be that Ben sent Alex and her companions into a trap. However, the only possible motive for doing so is that Ben arranged for Rosseau and Carl to be killed so that he would be the only person Alex would love. I find that a hard motive to swallow even if one posits that Ben is amoral. Instead, the more logical conclusion is that the mercenaries from the Barge are the assassins. Coincidentally, this episode informed us that the Barge is controlled by a seemingly violent clique of mercenaries shooting semi-automatic weapons for sport. This is consistent with sniper fire in the jungle. Also, the fighting capabilities of the Others have been substantially degraded by their failed assault on the beach. The Barge mercenaries could easily have arrived on the Island by helicopter. I note that the helicopter was not seen on the Barge during this episode. Also, the timing of a landing is appropriate as the Barge likely held off a full landing on the Island until the poisoning ability of the Tempest was neutralized.
3. Benjamin Linus placed the phony Flight 815 at the bottom of the Ocean There are two conflicting stories presented: (a) the Barge captain claims that Ben did the plant; and (b) Tom claims that Widmore was the one who staged the crash. I believe the version that Ben is responsible for this subterfuge. All the papers which Tom shows Michael could just have easily been generated by Ben in accomplishing the same task. Also, the reason Tom gives -- that Widmore does not want anyone else to find the Island -- does not make much sense. It is the Others who have worked hard to prevent the Island from being detected. Indeed, the Others seem unconcerned that the survivors would be discovered further evidencing that they deliberately plated a decoy crashed Flight 815.
4. Neither the Others nor Widmore are completely good or evil. Each side has its own agenda and views itself as being in the right. Simlarly, each side is willing to do within reason what is necessary to accomplish their respective goals. Each side accuses the other of being evil and proclaims their own goodness. However, the likely reality is that these are just competing side in a struggle for control of the Island and whatever powers or unique attributes the Island possesses.
5. The Island’s powers appear to be such that those that leave cannot die an unnatural death upon leaving. Michael cannot kill himself. In an earlier flashback, Jack did not have much luck attempting suicide either. This would make the Island analogous to Planet Krypton for Superman. The alternative explanation is that the Island is a separate living entity which is actually preventing Michael from killing himself. To me, that is a more difficult theory to swallow though, then again, this is LOST.
Sunday, March 30, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment